Curtain Call 커튼콜
KBS2 (2022) 16 Episodes
Family Melodrama, North-South Conflict
Grade: A+
Korean Drama Review by Jill, USA (Some Spoilers) "A Tree Dies Standing"
~~~~~~~~~~~
A
powerful and poignant family-themed Korean drama with
an exceptional cast, destined to be a classic, Curtain
Call (2022) spanned the years 1950 (the
beginning of the Korean War) to the modern era in
2022, and covered some tensions typical to both South
and North Korean populations. The director was the
renowned, brilliant Yoon Sang Ho (producer of the
classic 1998 film Christmas In August, which
every Korean knows like the back of their hand) who
directed some of my top favorite Korean dramas of all
time, including Saimdang,
Light's Diary, Bae Yong Joon's The
Legend, Tamra
The Island, and Different
Dreams. The writer was Jo Sung Geol who
has done a couple of dark films on hit-men and
zombies, so I wasn't sure how I would react to this
story, but it was definitely a departure from those
bleak films, to focus on a family who, by and large,
were pretty wholesome in their outlooks on life. There
were a couple of plot points I would have done
differently, if I were the writer, but I wasn't, so
dream on, Jill. ;)
My Favorite Curtain Call OST
Song
Sung By My Favorite Korean Singer
Sung Si Kyung
The lead
actress was the one and only sublime Ha Ji Won, whom
I've been watching in dramas and films for over two
decades, including the classic Secret
Garden, King
2 Hearts, Empress
Ki, Damo,
Secret,
The
Time We Were Not In Love, and films Ditto,
Phone, Love So Divine, and Daddy
Long Legs. I'll watch her in anything, she is
a total delight.
(And since her co-star in
the 2004 film Love So Divine, Kwon Sang Woo,
above, made an appearance in Curtain Call,
it was like Old Home Week for me to see them
together again after eighteen long years! I loved
the way they looked at each in this drama, you could
see the memories of that hilarious earlier film in
their twinkling eyes!).
Male lead was the
fantastic Kang Ha Neul, a consummate actor who can
play any role imaginable, best known for great
dramas and films like Angel
Eyes, Misaeng,
To
The Beautiful You, Missing
Noir M, Moon
Lovers, When
The Camellia Blooms, Heirs,
unforgettable film Dong Ju: Portrait Of A Poet,
Waiting For Rain, and the sequel to The
Pirates. As sweet counterpoint to the story we
have the flawless veteran actress of many dramas and
films going back three decades, Go Doo Shim (i.e. Our
Gab Soon, Swallow
The Sun, Snow
Queen, Sparkling
- All That Glitters, Dear
My Friends, My
Mister, When
The Camellia Blooms), playing Ha Ji
Won's grandmother, the center of the story. In real
life she's a lot younger than the elderly, dying
woman character in her nineties whom she plays here,
but a lot of elderly women do tend to look
younger than their years, especially if they've
never smoked, and we never see this character smoke
throughout her entire life.
Ha Ji Won, Playing Grandma When
Young (Above) and Her Granddaughter In 2022 (Below) Does This Actress Look
Forty-Four Years Old To You Here? ;)
The Story:
A married young mother named Ja Geum Soon (Ha Ji Won
when young, Go Doo Shim when old), and her loving
husband Ri Jong Moon (Kang Ha Neul), try to escape
warring North Korea one late night in 1950 when some
foreign ships try to rescue villagers at their
seaside town. Throngs of village people yearning to
be free rush to the waterside at night and try to
board the ships, some falling into the water and
unable to climb up the rope ladders thrown down to
them. When a nearby mother loses her little child Ri
Jong Moon rescues the child but loses his chance to
climb up the rope ladder to his wife, who had made
it onto the ship safely. "Survive!" the husband
cries out to his totally distraught wife, while
holding their water-sogged infant baby in his arms.
They are never to see each other again. The husband
dies later in North Korea. Their son Ri Yeong Hoon
(Kim Young Min, Beethoven
Virus, My
Mister) grows up resenting his mother
for what he unfairly sees as her abandonment of him
and his father. In time he ends up having his own
little son (though we never see the child's mother)
whom he names Ri Moon Seong (Kang Ji Young) who
yearns to meet his grandmother in South Korea
someday.
This Incredible
Scene Must Have Cost A Fortune To Film!
As the years pass in South Korea, Ja Geum Soon
remarries and has more children of her own, and then
her share of grandchildren as well. She works hard
and opens her own restaurant and eventually her own
luxury high-rise hotel in Seoul that she calls the
Nakwon Hotel. Her granddaughter Park Se Yeon (Ha Ji
Won again) runs the hotel as administrator, and
another grandson named Park Se Joon (Ji Seung Hyun,
Descendants
Of The Sun, Kang
Goo's Story, Search:
WWW) manages the finances (watch out!).
A third grandson Park Se Gyu (Choi Dae Hoon) is
rather a loafer, an alcoholic, and likes to impress
his friends in bars with his money from Grandma, but
he's basically only good for some comic relief in
the long scheme of things. (Why in the world did
he become my favorite character by the end? LOL!
Anyone who makes me laugh that much in a drama or
film I'm a sucker for! I hope I see this actor in
something again soon!).
Reunion With His Mother Ja
Geum Soon:
Ri Yeong Hoon (Kim Young Min) Can't Hide His
Sadness
During an internationally
planned North-South Korea Family Reunion Day (based
on a real life event) finally the middle aged Ja
Geum Soon meets her lost baby son from North Korea,
Ri Yeong Hoon, all grown up now, and with his own
little son Moon Seong coming along for the big
event. There is joy in their meeting, but also
recriminations between these three estranged family
members. Ja Geum Soon promises her little North
Korean grandson to see him the following year again
in another reunion, but it never happens. Ri Yeong
Hoon ends up dying suddenly, leaving his son all
alone. Moon Seong grows up to be a criminal, and
hating the grandmother he feels abandoned him after
his father's passing.
More time passes. Ja Geum Soon approaches the end of
her life, is diagnosed with cancer, and is told by
her doctor (Ahn Nae Sang) that she only has a few
months to live. Her faithful male assistant Jung
Sang Cheol (Sung Dong Il, It's Okay
That's Love, Jirisan)
develops a plan to help bring peace to Grandma
before she dies: he will hire an actor to
pose as her long missing North Korean grandchild,
Moon Seong!
He seeks out and hires Yoo Jae Heon (Kang Ha Neul),
a struggling stage actor who has been playing a
North Korean soldier in a local theater performance.
Yoo Jae Heon ends up with a pretend wife as well,
Seo Yoon Hee (Jung Ji So, very sweet performance),
his fellow thespian in their acting troupe, who is
secretly in love with him. He is told to pose as
Grandma's North Korean defector grandson Moon Seong
who has come to visit his grandmother for a while
before returning to the North. This he ends up doing
incredibly well, impressing the entire family, and
bringing Grandma a lot of happiness in her dying
days. Jae Heon gets along especially well with
granddaughter Park Se Yeon (Ha Ji Won again). He
takes her side when her brother Se Joon attempts to
sell the hotel, but is sad when Se Yeon agrees to
marry an old fiancee named Bae Dong Je (Kwon Sang
Woo) because if she co-owned his shares in the hotel
she could prevent the forced sale of Grandma's hotel
that she had built from scratch.
While this "stage play"
is taking place in the family in South Korea, the
criminal adult grandson (Noh Sang Hyun) in North
Korea finagles his way to China and then South
Korea. His resentment against Grandma is formidable
(as if it's her fault the communists took over the
North and separated their family!), and his
motivation is to cause her pain in her last days,
not happiness. Cruel! Eventually the truth about Jae
Hoon's real identity as a "mere actor" is revealed
to one and all, and the North Korean Moon Seong
slowly introduces himself to Grandma's extended
family as the "real" North Korean grandson. Jae Heon
even tries to be nice to him, but will this
non-smiling, resentful criminal from the North ever
warm up to his biological family and their friends,
or will he simply continue to show up for his share
of the inheritance when Grandma dies?
Jae Heon Loving Dying Grandma Far More Than
Moon Seong
Okay. I am going to take the liberty to say here
what I would have done differently with this
incredible story if I had written it. :) And
why, although I gave it an A+ grade because I loved
it overall, I do not consider it worthy of the
description Masterpiece.
First: Since Grandma's first husband when she
was young in North Korea is played by the same
actor, Kang Ha Neul, who plays the "fake" grandson
decades later to comfort Grandma in her dying days,
and the two characters are therefore the spitting
image of each other, it's only natural that some
audience members would wonder if Kang Ha Neul's Jae
Heon actor character could have been the REAL
grandson, and not the "fake". The writer made it a
point to show that the character of Jae Heon didn't
have a family; we are only shown him abandoned at a
theme park as a child by someone who could have been
an adoptive "mother", and he would have been raised
by an orphanage. Grandma's family could very easily
have been his real family after all, especially if
two infants in the first scene in the drama were
switched after falling in the water. I feel the
production team should have used a different actor
in the first scene of this drama when all the
villagers were trying to escape North Korea at war
in 1950. It would have made the situation so much
clearer. What are the chances that two men who look
exactly alike are unrelated? Practically nil.
That threw me off for the entire production. I
consider that unfair to the audience. If they were
going to use the same actor then I would have
written a big surprise near the end of the drama and
made Kang Ha Neul's Jae Heon character the real
grandson, corroborated through legitimate DNA
testings.
Second: There is
no way the sweet little boy they showed at the
family reunion when Grandma was middle aged could
have grown up to be a hardened criminal, a drug
dealer, even a murderer: an orphanage would have
taken the boy and cared for him. Even in North Korea
there are orphanages. We aren't shown what happened
to him in the interim to make him such a
non-smiling, hard-hearted bastard out to destroy
Grandma. Plus in a flashback scene we are shown the
"real" Moon Seong had a wife who needed a liver
transplant. Then we never see this woman again and
Moon Seong never returns to North Korea to take care
of her and make sure she got her transplant. The
woman would have died and Moon Seong would have had
yet another death on his hands. Sloppy
writing!
Third: We are suddenly told at the end of
the story that Grandma knew all along that Jae Heon
was fake, an actor playing a part. HOGWASH! Not
when he walked up to her on the lawn for the first
time and was the spitting image of her late first
husband in North Korea! The woman was smart, but not
THAT smart! We are given no tip offs that she ever
once doubted he was Moon Seong, until that last
scene. More implausible sloppy writing!
It seemed like everything
was put together in this show to guarantee that
actor Jae Heon and granddaughter Se Yeon would be a
romantic couple at the conclusion of the story,
because they were no longer considered related. Ho
hum. In real life in many countries cousins marry
quite often, so they still could have made Jae Heon
the real grandson and had them marry in the end. I
confess I didn't need the kind of a soft ending we
got here, even though I love both actors, in a drama
that could have been even more memorable if a huge
revelation about the actor character being the real
grandson could have been made in a triumphant,
dramatic way. That I would have cheered for, big
time. Jae Heon was far more a real grandson to dying
Grandma than the "real" Moon Seong could ever be. If
it's Love that determines a family, and not just a
bloodline, then Jae Heon is far more of a true
Grandson to Grandma than the non-smiling, revengeful
criminal Moon Seong. Lots of people have sad
childhoods but they don't turn into vengeful
criminals. No excuses for that North Korean loser,
Moon Seong.
Now I feel better, getting all that off my chest.
LOL
You can watch Curtain Call at Viki at this
link. Enjoy!