Maids
하녀들
jtbc (2015) 20 Episodes
Historical Melodrama, Grade: C
Korean Drama Review by Jill, USA
~~~~~~~~~
While Maids (2015)
wasn't the best historical drama I've ever seen (that
honor goes to Chuno),
it had its interesting moments; however they were few
and far between and I struggled to complete this show;
it took me weeks, off and on, when I am usually a
marathoner when I really fall in love with a
show. Maybe I would have liked it more if I had watched
it as my 10th or 20th K-drama, but not when it was my
203rd, and I have practically seen everything of value
already made in the last fifteen years.
My main reason for giving it a rather
poor grade of C was that I didn't see any exciting
chemistry between the leads, actor Oh Ji Ho (Chuno)
and Jung Yumi (she played the evil sister in Rooftop
Prince). It felt forced to me, and
lacked tenderness. There was only one kiss in the entire
show. The opening moments turned me off, as he placed a
rope around her neck and dragged her with violence in an
attempt to harm her because she had become a slave. This
is supposed to be evidence of a man capable of "love"?
LOL. Maybe to sadists, but not normal people.
I really do think there are people today, mostly men,
who get off watching scenes like this one in sageuks
that degrade and cause violence to women. Of course they
would protest mightily if you said that to them, but I
really do think it's true in a lot of cases. They don't
know how to effectively deal with the complexity of most
women so live out their fantasies watching these kinds
of shows. All I can be thankful for is that I live in
the 21st century when women can fight back against
abuse, vote, have rights to property, business, choose
to have children or not, and to tell a bad-ass guy to
"Cojo!" ("Get lost!" in Korean). Honestly, you're not
going to miss much of anything by avoiding this sageuk.
Sorry, didn't buy their
relationship for one moment
The Story: Gook In Yub (Jung
Yumi) was a former noble lady who became a slave after
her family are branded as traitors. She had befriended
fellow servants and among them was a stoic and secretive
man named Moo Myung (Oh Ji Ho). When her fate takes a
turn for the worse their relationship changes from noble
and servant to equals as slaves / servants. They
eventually fall in love with each other, but get
entangled in political and class turmoils. She uses her
wits to survive and he uses his physical strengths and
good looks. Yawn. Seen it all before. This show could
really have been kept at 16 or even 12 episodes and told
the same story. Moral is: thank God you were not born in
the Joseon Era! The ambiguous ending does not help
matters.
Really, folks, if you love actor Oh Ji Ho, go watch his
masterpiece Chuno
instead! At least that show depicts him as a good, even
great man who is kind toward women. This show did not
show him off to his best advantage and I'm actually
surprised he took the job! (Probably sold a bill of
goods at the time by producers).